Plato plus his student Aristotle proposed the earliest identified by theories of literature inside Western philosophy. The particular art form that most concerned them was drama. In his Republic, Plato presented a design for an ideal state. In the course of outlining his utopia, he argued that poets—particularly dramatists—must be outlawed. In order to justify the exclusion of dramatic poets from the ideal state, Plato had to give reasons. Plus the reasons Plato found had to do with what he regarded as the nature of drama. According to Plato, the essence of drama be imitation—the simulation of appearances. That is, actors in plays imitate the actions of whomever they represent. In Media, the actors, for example, imitate having arguments. Plato thought that this be problematic primarily for the reason that he believed that appearances appeal to the emotions plus that stirring up the emotions be socially dangerous
Arguments like Plato's against poetry are still
heard today when it comes to discussions of the
mass media. Often we are told that TV with its
seductive imagery its seductive appearances makes
for an unthinking electorate. Carefully designed,
visually arresting, political advertisements appeal
to the emotions of the voters rather than to their
minds. If Plato were alive today, he would probably
want to censor political advertisements for the
same reason that he wanted to ban dramatic poetry.
|